Alright. I hear ya. Yer trying to teach this half-life thing to either no success or such limited success that you are thinking about considering your Mother's advise and become a Nun... Well, the Nunery kicked me out, so....
Here is a cute little 'half-life' LAB I saw today (05/01/02) from a colleague PhySci teacher, Justine Ruth, as I said, one of the 'up and coming' STARS of teaching. It is SO freekin' effective that I am almost ticked off that I didn't figure it out before... These kids...
She gives each kid, 9th grade level, a piece of graph paper and ONE strip of a TwizzlerTM strip. You know, the ones you bought for the trick-or-treaters, but you kept for yourself... Anyway, on the graph paper, the kids actually GRAPH the amount LEFT vs Number of Bites! Sounds weird, I know... But, read on....
STEPS?

Note the N is the amount of stuff left after time t, No is the amount of the original stuff, e is the exponential, k is supposed to be Lambda (a funny Greek letter), but it's tuff to write online, is the decay constant for that material. Mathematically, N can NEVER be zero. This is because No can't be zero and e-kt can ONLY be zero if -kt = INFINITY! That's a tough physical thing to happen. Thus N can never be zero. The graph will never touch the x-axis.
Follow the Twizzler LAB with the M&Mium LAB. Kids get 50 regular M&M's. Each represents a radioactive atom of the mysterious M&Mium element. In a cup, they shake the M&Miums and dump them on a clean piece of paper. Any M&M that has the 'M' facing up is still radioactive. The M&M's that have the blank side up has decayed into Blankium. Remove the Blankiums & count the remaining M&Miums. Place these remaining radioactive M&Miums back in the cup. Shake again. Repeat removal of Blankiums and counting of the remaining M&Miums till there are no more M&Miums left! Do this entire procedure at least two times to verify original numbers. If the numbers are whacko out of line with each other, do it all again. When the trials are done, I allow the counters to 'dispose' of the Blankiums. (Eating...)
Now, kids graph the results. Number of M&Miums (radioactive atoms remaining) vs number of shakes (number of half-lives). The graph should be identical to the Twizzler graph EXCEPT it ends by touching the x-axis! This follows reality where the radioactive sample will eventually disappear, unlike the mathematical prediction.